← Back to library

Judgment & Evidence · 3 MIN READ

Keep a forecast scorecard

A forecast should specify an event, a deadline, and an assessment made before the outcome is known.

Institute lesson · Published October 19, 2026

The idea

A forecast should specify an event, a deadline, and an assessment made before the outcome is known. Recording these elements makes later learning possible. Without a stable record, memory can quietly rewrite an uncertain prediction into something that felt obvious.

Worked example

A neighborhood organizer predicts a 70% chance that at least 40 people will attend Saturday’s cleanup, provided rain stays below a stated threshold. She records the number before sending invitations and defines how attendance will be counted. After the event she records the result and her reasons. Over many events, she checks whether events assigned about 70% occur roughly seven times in ten, rather than judging her skill from one lucky success.

Use it carefully

Calibration is a pattern across many forecasts; a single event cannot validate a probability. Forecasts also need useful discrimination: repeatedly saying 50% may avoid extreme mistakes while adding little practical help. Conditional forecasts require recording whether their conditions occurred. A scorecard is a tool for comparing judgment with reality, not a way to remove genuine uncertainty or turn social outcomes into mechanical laws.

FROM UNDERSTANDING TO ACTION

Put it to work.

Record three dated forecasts with explicit outcomes. Schedule a review and preserve your original reasoning.

RETRIEVE. REASON. REMEMBER.

Knowledge check.

Choose one answer for each question, then check your reasoning.

1. What makes a forecast auditable?
2. One successful 70% forecast demonstrates:

Sources & further reading.

Links support the core concepts or identify the book. Examples, exercises, and critical analysis are original Institute material. Source checks are not an independent expert review of every claim.

Editorial standards and corrections